Who won
I thought it was clearly Harman this week. She’s adopted a style I don’t remember seeing at PMQs before, but one that is very welcome and seemingly effective. Her questions are pertinent, but not shouted – it gives the impression of real scrutiny rather than petty political point scoring, which for too long has had its place at PMQs. It’s certainly a nice model after five years of Cameron’s face of mock incredulity which has accompanied every query he ever put across the Despatch Box, a face that made it look as though his eyebrows were trying to form a coalition with his hairline. Even now, it creates a wonderful antithesis as Cameron’s attacks on the previous government look increasingly hysterical compared to Harman’s cool interrogations. This was especially clear when his defence of the plans to change constituency sizes seemed to boil down to: “Well it may not be fair, but the current system isn’t that fair and YOU didn’t sort it out!”

Best question, comment or joke
There was nothing funny this week, really. People are going to go with David Cameron’s “Alf Garnett” joke on Ed Balls I’m sure, but was it actually funny? I know who Alf Garnett is, but I’m not sure I get it. Maybe people just liked it because it was aimed at Ed Balls.

Caroline Flint asked why those accused of rape deserve anonymity when it’s not given to those accused of other violent crimes. Cameron was shaky on it last week and seemed no better today. His “a lot of people are falsely accused of rape” line didn’t go down well, neither in the Commons or with me, sat here alone in my house, especially as he didn’t seem to have an answer. “We have to work together” to get more rape convictions is not an answer.

Best backbencher
Caroline Flint again, though I might pick Tory MP Jonathan Evans just because of his hilariously bad suit jacket. I ended up laughing so much I missed his question, but I think it was a planted one anyway. Perhaps ‘Jonathan Evans’ Jacket’ can go in the best joke section?!