
But the Sheffield Forgemasters scandal is going to swell as it shows the crude and incompetent workings of the ConDem government. It highlights how Nick Clegg does not understand that all politics is local and if you betray the city where you are an MP and viciously slur one of its most respected business leaders you will not be forgiven or forgotten.
Late last night in the Commons there were amazing scenes as a hapless Tory treasury minister had to explain why a top Tory donor had successfully intervened to stop the agreed loan of £80 million to Sheffield Forgemasters. Earlier this year treasury officials poured over the details of this loan needed to help the company buy a giant press to make forgings for the new nuclear plant needed to replace Britain’s ageing nuclear power stations.
Whitehall agreed that this loan which was hedged in with all sorts of qualifications was a good proposal even at a time of fiscal austerity.
Then came the election. Shortly after the ConDem government was formed from the right-wing Sheffield Tory businessman, Andrew Cook, told Cameron to kill the deal.
Cook has given £500,000 to the Tories and paid for plane flights by David Cameron. In Sheffield his reputation as a rightwing Europhobe, and union-busting boss is well known. There are other Cook stories not fit for a family website. His sister is the former Tory MP, Angela Knight, who heads the British Bankers’ Association. British banks, it was announced yesterday, have refused to step in and provide the loan for Sheffield Forgemasters on terms the company can afford.
Nick Clegg as a Sheffield MP should have tried to support this iconic Sheffield firm. All politics remains local. Can anyone imagine John Prescott sacrificing a Hull company to please the treasury? The loan could have been reduced or repackaged but Clegg rolled over to do what the Tories wanted.
But Clegg as we can see with his gaffe over the “illegal” Iraq war is just inexperienced. The idea that a minister can stand at the despatch box and speak in a personal capacity is as laughable as it is unconstitutional.
Clegg went further. On June 21 he made an extraordinary allegation against Sheffield Forgemaster’s CEO, Dr Graham Honeyman, namely that Dr Honeyman was protecting his shareholdings by not seeking private help also needed investigation. On 21 June Nick Clegg said: “Do I think it is the role of government to help out owners of companies who do not want to dilute their own shareholdings? No I don’t.” A furious Dr Honeyman wrote to the Yorkshire Post on 23 June rebutting Clegg’s and the PM’s allegations pointing out that “No dividends have been paid because this company does not hinge around making money for shareholders or individual gain. It has been at considerable personal risk that I have been involved” Honeyman declared.
These slurs and smears against Dr Honeyman are a disgrace. If Labour ministers had been involved in a similar scandal all hell would have let loose. But this story is not being picked up anywhere, so far. It should be as it shows both how Tory donors are now involved in key ConDem decisions, how Nick Clegg cannot help his own constituents and the city where he was parachuted in as an MP, and how he lashes out with foolish, ill-advised statements unbecoming an MP let alone a minister.
Last night in the Commons the saddest sight was Vince Cable, sitting hunched and miserable as Clive Betts, Angela Smith, Pat McFadden and Meg Munn unveiled this saga to an incredulous Commons. Tory whips came rushing in to try and get some ConDem MPs sitting to support their spokesman. Simon Hughes shrunk into the corner seat close to the bar of the Commons as if ashamed to have anything to do with Clegg, Cable and the other LibDem poodles.
This story is not over yet. But Nick Clegg will not win re-election in Sheffield unless as a Conservative Liberal without a Tory candidate against him.
Clegg’s duplicity and double dealing is clear and should be rightfully exposed but there is a bit missing from this article because it does not explain why the right-wing Tory businessman wanted this loan deal scuppered. Some words seem to be missing ! It would be nice to know !
Denis, worth reading Dr Honeyman’s comments the week before as well as his 23 June letter. On 17 June the Yorkshire Post reports him as saying: “Private equity would take the whole of the shareholding away from Forgemasters and put it in the hands of somebody else” “The reason why we went to the government is the interest rates were reasonable. Bank interest rates are very high therefore we would have to make huge profits every year in order just to pay off interest on the debt.” I think it is rather naive to think a businessman who owns 49% of a company does not operate with a degree of financial self-interest. http://www.yorkshirepost.co.uk/businessnews/We-wont-give-up-yet.6370013.jp
Well done Dennis and for my MP Meg and Angela and Clive for exposing this. How can Clegg face Sheffielders, the City of Steel, when he has done more singlehandedly to allow the destruction of our heritage than any individual with any power in the City. I hope his constituents are as furious as I am.
Good stuff, as usual, Dennis. The story made the front page of the Guardian today. This could be the end of boy, behaving like one, Clegg in Sheffield and he will, perhaps, have to be parachuted in to a safe LibDem seat. Another oxymoron! Will he see the thousand, sorry, five years out as Leader, though? Will he become what he has always been and join the Tories? Oh, and the Economy perked up between April and June mainly due to construction (everybody including my great aunt Nan who had her drive relaid) is taking credit. No chance of that happening again then.