This is it.
The decision the country makes tomorrow is irreversible – if we decide to leave the European Union.
It took a prime ministerial intervention on the steps of Downing Street yesterday, to make this point forcefully – particularly in the terms David Cameron made it in, which is that this is a vote which will impact on our children and grandchildren (who cannot vote) at least as much as it will us.
Too much has already needed to be written about the way that the Leave case has been prosecuted in shrill rhetoric, while Remain’s case has been more dowdy prose. Arguing for change is always more exciting than advocating the status quo.
Yet what is Leave’s case?
There are Eurosceptics – admittedly not the cynical arrivistes like Boris Johnson – who have been advocating Brexit for years, if not decades. So why, when it comes to it, is the Vote Leave camp no clearer about what Brexit will look like? They have failed utterly to tell us how we will make our way once we leave the EU. We could copy Norway, or Switzerland, or Canada – to name but three – we are told, but which?
I know the terrain if we vote to stay in the EU. I am utterly unclear and perplexed what path we follow if we leave.
Eventually our economy will probably right itself. As Danny Finkelstein argues compellingly today, ironically it may turn out to rely on the sort of low wages, insecurity and immigration which politically motivates people to vote for change. Life, and the way we make a living, will continue.
But what tumult will we have to go through to get there? And why aren’t we told what course we will steer instead? Instead, those who ask these impertinent questions are told that we are prosecuting Project Fear. Or that we are unpatriotic, belittling the potential to make Britain great again. Or that – worst of all – people want to take control and get their country back.
What bunkum.
How is it scare-mongering to point out the flimsiness, the uncertainty of the case made? To say that the vast majority of those awful experts, like economists and doctors – all of whom have as much say and stake as anyone else – think on balance Remain is better for the economy and the NHS?
How is it unpatriotic to argue that we shouldn’t run from the world, that we are a leading nation of the world and we treasure our unique position as a bridge between the US and Europe, enjoying favoured status in both camps? That we fought a war to bring peace to our continent which we now want to guard jealously? Should the patriot should pursue a course of action backed by none of our allies, but endorsed by Vladimir Putin?
And as for taking control; regaining our sovereignty from unelected elites? Is Leave calling to scrap the House of Lords or the pooling of sovereignty our four nations have made over the course of centuries?
If there is a failure in the Remain camp it is the failure to properly address and answer the charge that Brexit is a magic want to ‘get our country back’. As Howard Jacobson eloquently put it on Newsnight last night:
I have a great deal of sympathy for people who live in areas where they sometimes don’t hear their own language spoken. I don’t think we should talk about racists the way we sometimes do. But when we hear people saying I want my country back, that’s terrifying. It wasn’t that long ago when we saw what people saying “I want my country back” led to.
This country has not been taken over; we are not occupied. We have a distinct, vibrant culture. We are ourselves. We have got nothing to fear about being taken over. It is wicked language; it is terrifying language.
We have always prospered by looking outwards, by rejecting insularity. Even Leave argues we are great trading nation; why wouldn’t we want to stay part of the largest trading bloc the world has ever seen?
We are a great country already. Britain at is best doesn’t shirk its challenges nor sulks in the corner; we face up to our problems, create alliances and work to build peace and prosperity.
As Labour people, we know we can achieve more by common endeavour than we can alone. Nowhere is this truer than in Europe.
In short, we are truly Stronger In. We should vote to Remain tomorrow.
————————————
Mike Katz is a Labour activist. He tweets @MikeKatz
————————————
Immigration not a stinking rotten MP anywhere has ever lifted a solitary finger to help these poor wretches, you enjoy a lil bit of shocky and awry we use to destroy their countries, killing countless thousands, devastating their infrastructure, and making them homeless
Then what do you do WE MUST HELP THESE PEOPLE ITS OUR DUTY, accompanied by an orchestra and some bleeding hearts
Fact as i said not a stinking politician as ever lifted a finger to help them, you wave them in and that’s it
You see refugee or immigrant children don’t mix with thechildren of gliterati politicians ,,their children are either attending schools in upmarket areas or go to public schools.How you love thoe refugees you created As long as any don’t mix with their precious little darlings .So no burden there
Health services MPS in the main don’t join the queue They are private So no burden there
You see politicians would rather the poorest in society do the helping, hence they rather enjoy putting the burden on them To get them processed, their health concerns, housing and so on in other words forcing people who have virtually noting to give share what little they have
They are the real heroes, the poor people, charities, not thieves like Cooper and co who earn £1000s but still deem it not enough
No one has explained to me the point of Labour They are nothing but a 2rd rate Tory party The only purpose for their being is to guarantee a Tory party victory, and to give the current political system they created credibility
From a former Labour voter.. i absolutely despise the monster you’v become You are beneath contempt
<<"my room mate Mary Is getting paid on the internet $98/hr"…..!kj434n:
two days ago grey McLaren. P1 I bought after earning 18,512 Dollars..it was my previous month's payout..just a little over.17k Dollars Last month..3-5 hours job a day…with weekly payouts..it's realy the simplest. job I have ever Do.. I Joined This 7 months. ago. and now making over hourly. 87 Dollars…Learn. More right Here
!kj434n:
➽:➽:.
➽.➽.➽.➽ http://GlobalSuperJobsReportsEmploymentsCommonGetPay$98Hour…..
★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹:★✹::::::!kj434n….,..
If the EU is so bloody wonderful, why haven’t Switzerland and Norway joined it? Could someone please answer this simple question?